A spokesperson for Victoria Police characterized the recent shooting incident as “extremely volatile and high-risk.” This description underscores the harrowing reality faced by officers when making split-second decisions that have profound consequences. The department, however, has emphatically denied any implications that racism played a role in the tragic event.
- Advertisement -
In a regrettable twist of fate, the two officers involved in the incident—a sergeant and a constable—were not equipped with Tasers. Despite Victoria Police’s initiative launched in 2021 to equip all frontline officers with this non-lethal option, only around 60% currently have access to Tasers. The full deployment of this essential tool is not expected to be completed until September 2026—a timeline that has caused concern among community members and advocates alike.
The seriousness of the situation has prompted the Homicide Squad to take the lead on the investigation, supported by the Professional Standards Command. As is standard in such cases, the coroner will also be reviewing the details surrounding this tragic event. The thoroughness of such inquiries is paramount, aiming to ensure transparency and accountability.
On April 22, the streets of Footscray witnessed a significant display of community unrest as approximately 200 protesters gathered on Nicholson Street. Armed with signs emblazoned with phrases such as “Black Lives Matter,” “Justice for Abdifatah,” and “Mental Health Needs Care, Not Bullets,” these individuals sought to amplify their voices in the face of perceived injustice. Tensions surged momentarily when a faction of around 30 demonstrators had a brief clash with the police, throwing bottles in frustration. Thankfully, no injuries were reported during this exchange, but the incident highlighted the palpable emotions that fueled the gathering.
Farah Warsame, president of Somali Community Inc., expressed her dismay, reflecting the overwhelming sentiment within the community: “We are still wondering why the police didn’t use any other means—like capsicum spray or a Taser—to de-escalate the situation. It is human life at the end of the day.” Her words resonate deeply, sparking an important question: when does a tactical decision blur the lines of humanity?
Dr. Berhan Ahmed, the CEO of Africause, also took to the stage to honor the memory of Abdifatah. “He was a gentleman,” Dr. Ahmed recalled. His comment shed light on the potential futures lost when lives are cut short. He insisted that the real problem lies in the systems that fail these young people, reminding us that “we don’t need to blame victims—we need to support them.” These statements serve as a poignant reminder of the responsibilities society holds towards its vulnerable populations.
Somali community advocate Ibrahim Abdulahi Ali raised critical concerns regarding police conduct during the incident. He questioned whether standard de-escalation protocols were followed and urged the immediate release of any body-worn camera footage to promote transparency. “This is about a pattern,” he stated in a social media post, raising a thought-provoking point. “A system. A long history of Black lives being ended by state violence—and the same recycled statements following each one.” His call for accountability challenges us to introspect on the mechanisms in our society that perpetuate violence against marginalized communities.
Victoria Police Commander Timothy Tully confirmed that while the officers involved have been placed on leave, they will not be suspended from duty. “This was an incident that could have impacted the safety of a large number of people who were in the area,” he noted. While the intent to ensure community safety is commendable, the underlying question remains: Is a system designed for safety truly serving its purpose when it results in such outcomes?
The City of Maribyrnong has echoed the community’s calls, releasing a statement in support of an independent review of the incident. “We remain committed to a partnership-based approach with our community leaders, seeking long-term solutions to the social and mental health challenges impacting Footscray,” it asserted. This commitment to collaboration indicates a positive step towards addressing the root causes of distress in the community.
Moreover, Australia’s broader mental health response system is under the microscope, especially in light of a parliamentary inquiry in New South Wales. This inquiry has proposed alternative emergency response models, reflecting the urgent need for innovative solutions to prevent similar tragedies involving individuals in mental distress.
In the aftermath of this devastating incident, the Somali-Australian community perseveres in seeking clarity, justice, and, ultimately, the meaningful change that will pave the way for a safer future for all. It poses a critical question for us all: How can we work together to reshape systems that seem to perpetuate cycles of violence? In the words of Nelson Mandela, “What counts in life is not the mere fact that we have lived. It is what difference we have made to the lives of others that will determine the significance of the life we lead.”
As this investigation unfolds and discussions about systemic change continue, one hopes that the echoes of past experiences will inform a more compassionate and equitable approach to policing and community safety.
Edited By Ali Musa
Axadle Times International – Monitoring
